[General] Update on Feature List

Philippe Bossut pbossut at osafoundation.org
Wed Jul 25 09:39:27 PDT 2007


Hi Mimi,

This is a pretty good first shot. Here's some comments and proposals for 
improvements. I'm ready to do it if you're OK with them.

Mimi Yin wrote:
> I have done a pass at the Feature 
> List: http://chandlerproject.org/Planning/Features
On the form first:
- There are some inconsistencies in the presentation: sometimes the 
whole first statement is bold, sometimes not, sometimes it introduces an 
explanatory paragraph starting with semi colon, sometimes it's part of 
the sentence. The feeling is that it reads more like a marketing 
pamphlet than a feature list.
-> Proposal: I can edit and clean that up, I'll keep the active form you 
use to describe the features, using verbs to introduce the feature and 
separate the short description from the paragraph with a semi colon.
- Statements are fuzzy: qualifiers like "smart", "easy" don't carry any 
useful information since their alternative are not credible. All they do 
is avoid describing what the feature really does.
-> Proposal: I can edit that too, suppressing the fluffy qualifiers and 
adding some meat to the description. You may want to proof read after 
I'm done though since I'm not an English native speaker.

Unclear Titles
- "Managing Information with the Desktop": This is confusing to new 
comers I'm afraid. You certainly mean "Chandler the Desktop Application" 
but, for anyone not familiar with OSAF's jargon, this reads as if 
Chandler is providing some kind of desktop utilities integrated within 
the OS desktop.
-> Proposal: Change this to "Manage Information with the Desktop 
Application"
- "Interoperate": Again, this is OSAF's jargon. I'd prefer "Compatible" 
as "compatibility" is what end users are really looking for.
-> Proposal: Change to "Compatible with other applications"


> *The question of the day is: What's missing?*

- Support for email: Email is only mentioned as a collaborative tool. I 
think we should mention it as a way to get items into Chandler in the 
"manage" section. This is a very important feature I think.
- Stamping: Hard to explain in one paragraph but important since it's so 
central to Chandler.
- Dashboard: The name is not mentioned (instead, we talk about a "Triage 
Table"). Again, since it's so central to Chandler and right up on the 
UI, we should mention the term and explain.
-> Proposal: I can take a shot at adding those if you're OK with it.

Cheers,
- Philippe



More information about the General mailing list