[chandler-users] [Bulk] Sorting
Mimi Yin
mimi at osafoundation.org
Tue Oct 28 07:09:53 PDT 2008
Good idea Fritz.
Perhaps we should revive the "Known Issues" page and put it there? It
was put together a year ago for Preview, so it's sadly out of date. I
can take a look at cleaning it up.
http://chandlerproject.org/knownissues
In terms of what can we do to make this less confusing / more
understandable...Some ideas we've been batting around include:
- Adding "gray labels" to the dates so you know what kind of date
you're looking at (similar to the Who column. (Rem(inder), St(art), Ed
(ited) on, Cr(eated) on.)
-- https://bugzilla.osafoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=12257
- Sort non-alarmed and non-calendar items in the LATER section is
based on the "Edited / Created on" date, which is visible in the date
column, not when the item was triaged to LATER, which is not visible.
- Sort the DONE section based on the date that's visible in the date
column. This means that you will not be guaranteed to see the items
you most recently triaged to DONE at the top of the list, but
probably 90% of the time, you will.
My understanding is, this is the sorting behavior that Jeffrey has
been working on for the re-architecture.
See proposal on Chandler-Dev: http://lists.osafoundation.org/
pipermail/chandler-dev/2008-October/010373.html
Mimi
On Oct 28, 2008, at 3:22 AM, Fritz Meissner wrote:
> Hi Keith,
> That certainly helped me a lot to understand this under-documented
> aspect of Chandler. Can I suggest that you put this info into the
> wiki ? I don't think that this is there yet, and I think that it is
> essential info for all new Chandler users.
>
> Regards,
> Fritz
>
> 2008/10/28 Keith Winsor <kjwstuff at btopenworld.com>
> Hi Ann,
>
> Comments below, but first a little background info.
>
> As you rightly say, sorting has been discussed in a few posts. The
> basic premise of Chandler organisation is that items are triaged
> into three sections: Now, Later, Done. Items can optionally have
> alarms set and, when those alarms in Later trigger, the item
> automatically pops into the Now section. Un-alarmed Later items pop
> to Now on their due date, so you can do the GtD thing of forgetting
> about stuff until it gets 'tickled'.
>
> Sorting into the appropriate section is achieved by simply clicking
> repeatedly on the Now/Later/Done icon. The problem is, if you click
> on something flagged as Now, you don't want it disappearing into
> Later immediately, if your intention was to click twice and mark it
> as done. So the operation is carried out in two stages: first you
> change the status of all the items you want to change, then you hit
> the Cleanup button (originally marked 'Triage') to despatch them to
> the appropriate section.
>
> When alarms fire or when an item is edited by someone else, that
> item jumps back to Now, even if it is marked as Later, to bring to
> your attention that something has changed. These items jump to the
> top of the Now section, regardless of their actual due date.
> Similarly, items passing their due date change automatically to
> Done, unless they are marked as Starred (i.e. tasks). So an
> appointment passing its due date is marked as Done, but a task
> passing its due date is only Done when you say it is. There are a
> few bugs in this behaviour, mostly to do with repeating items, but
> that's the theory of how it all hangs together.
>
> Having got that out of the way, on to sorting...
>
> Mimi summarised sorting proposals like this on October 1st (my
> comments interspersed):
>
> NOW
> - Continue to sort NOW by triageStatusChanged (aka when an item
> becomes NOW)
> - Allow NOW items to be manually re-ordered.
>
> So at present Now sorts by the date the item was stamped Now,
> irrespective of its due date.
>
> LATER
> - Continue to sort LATER items that have custom-date tickler alarms
> and/or events to the top of the LATER section, leaving date-less
> Someday Maybe items at the bottom.
> - Change the way Someday Maybe items are sorted by sorting on the
> "Edited on" date, aka the date that appears in the Date column.
>
> and Later sorts by event date/alarm date, with undated items
> sorting to the bottom
>
> DONE
> - Sort the DONE section by whatever appears in the Date column:
> Custom-date tickler alarm, Event date, Edited on date.
>
> At present, I think there is a lot of confusion caused by sorting
> on fields that aren't necessarily even visible, such as the Last
> Edited Date.
>
> For me, the logical solution would be to follow the traditional
> secondary/primary sort method: click on title column header then
> date column header results in 'sort by date, then title'. Except
> Now items that have been automatically changed by the system in
> some way, or edited by someone else, which should sort to the top.
> In addition, a lot of people have requested the ability to manually
> sort the Now section...
>
> Later is a can of worms, as this Bugzilla page attests. Do you sort
> by due date? What about those items with an alarm a fortnight
> before their due date - should they be sorted by alarm date instead?
>
> Done should be sorted by completion date, the date the item was
> marked Done.
>
> The real difficulty is, bearing in mind each section is sorting on
> a potentially different set of criteria, how do you display this in
> table view? Ideally, the top of each section would display in some
> way the sort criteria being used.
>
>
> Ann Norcross wrote:
>>
>> I have some questions about sorting.
>>
>> I know that sorting of the Triage list has had a few posts, and
>> I'm sorry to start off with such a negative attitude, but I have
>> to say that I am so totally confused by the sort mechanism that I
>> really don't know how I can use the Dashboard or any of my
>> collecitons. Seriously.
>>
>> Here's a run-down of what I do, what I expect, and what happens,
>> in case it is at all useful...
>>
>> Any hints on how to understand the sort would also be helpful to me.
>>
>> From Dashboard view, I press ...
>> ... the little squiggly triangle at the top of the last coulumn
>> until the NOW items are at the top.
>> ... the bigger squiggly triangle labeled CLEANUP at the top of the
>> screen
>>
>> I expect...
>> ... to see a series of NOW items sorted by date.
>> ... that if I press the little sguiggly triangle again, I'll see
>> all my LATER items at the top, sorted by date.
>>
> Now I would have expected this to reverse the sort, so Done came to
> the top, with Now at the bottom.
>
>> ... that if I press the little sguiggly triangle a third time,
>> I'll see all my DONE items at the top, sorted by date.
>>
> The closest Chandler offers at the moment is to click downward-
> facing arrow adjacent the word Now in the grey section header. This
> hide all the items in that section. Click again to view. I
> generally leave my Done section hidden, as it makes the scroll bar
> bigger.
>
>> Instead, I see...
>> ... a series of NOW items sorted arbitarily, not by date, not by
>> title, not by person... I have absolutely no idea what I am
>> looking at, what is most important, and what I should pay
>> attention to next.
>> ... my LATER items sorted with all the alarmed items at the top,
>> soonest to farthest away, followed by all the rest of my LATER
>> items sorted arbitrarily, with some TODAY items at the top and
>> some at the bottom.
>> ... my DONE items sorted in no particular order that I can discern.
>>
>> So, perhaps Triage sort is not useful for me. Ok, no problem, I'll
>> try sorting by DATE, if that's what I want....
>>
>> From Dashboard view, I press ...
>> ... the DATE column-title
>>
>> I expect ...
>> ... to see all my NOW items sorted by ascending or descending date.
>> ... that if I press the DATE heading again, the sort order will
>> reverse.
>>
>>
> There's a strong argument for clicking on Date respecting the
> triage status and sorting just within each section.
>
>> Instead, I see ...
>> ... all my items (NOW, LATER, and DONE) merged togther and sorted
>> in one column in some arbitrary order, not date, not title, not
>> user. Again, I have no idea what I am looking at and what is
>> important.
>>
> Again, it's the sorting on a value you can't see that causes the
> confusion.
>
>> So, I press ...
>> ... DATE a second time, and it brings all the alrams to the top,
>> in no particular order... it looks like today's alarmed items are
>> on the bottom of the alarmed-items-group and the rest of the
>> alarmed items start at the top with farthest in the future and the
>> deadlines get closer as the list goes down.
>>
>> At this point, I start making lots of individual collections,
>> hoping to get the sort granualr enough that I can use it. That
>> doesn't work, either. I am frustrated, and retreat to my email
>> client as a task manager. Help.
>>
>> ann
> I think the key to successfully using Chandler is to keep the Now
> section down to immediate 'Next Actions', and triage to Later (with
> alarms for when you need to be reminded of them) all the 'soon but
> not yets'. By keeping it small, the somewhat (apparently) arbitrary
> sorting becomes less of an issue: you can still see the imminent
> items. Anything undated becomes 'Someday/Maybe', reviewed as and
> when you feel the need.
>
> Hope this explains, if not exactly clarifies. Let us know if you
> need more.
>
> All the best,
>
> Keith
>
> _______________________________________________
> chandler-users at osafoundation.org mailing list
> unsubscribe here: http://lists.osafoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/
> chandler-users
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> chandler-users at osafoundation.org mailing list
> unsubscribe here: http://lists.osafoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/
> chandler-users
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.osafoundation.org/pipermail/chandler-users/attachments/20081028/a77c642d/attachment.htm
More information about the chandler-users
mailing list